37 Comments
User's avatar
Ben's avatar

Combining:

1) The lack of congressional action on legislation regulating tech companies/ social media, even though many members state they strongly favor such legislation - both currently and when under single control by either party

2) The movement of the current SCOTUS towards implementing it’s major questions doctrine

Can we really expect any action from the federal government to install boundaries (legislative and/or regulatory requirements) on AI companies and their products?

Aaron Turner's avatar

(1) Will today's AI inexorably evolve (given sufficient time) into super-intelligent AGI?

(2) By how much will super-intelligent AGI be likely to amplify global GDP?

(3) Will super-intelligent AGI create mass technological employment?

(4) Will super-intelligent AGI significantly increase income/wealth inequality?

(5) Will super-intelligent AGI be a plausible existential threat to mankind?

FilAth's avatar

Thanks a lot for this. A great use case for LLMs is the ability to read papers and work as a personal RA (or better yet a personal tutor and ideas helper). I have tried to implement such a tool using ChatGPT’s API with word embeddings, plus I’ve tried askpdf and chatpdf. But results are pretty underwhelming. Do you have any advice on how to best design such a tool? Perhaps I need to do fine-tuning instead of just embeddings, or try better prompts.

BTW I used Kevin Bryan’s excellent toy code for this https://github.com/kevincure/YourPersonalAI

Jon Fischer's avatar

How will LLMs ever get over the hallucination problem? Or will they? Is there a solution that doesn't involve lots and lots of human-executed hard coding?

Alan Pease's avatar

Thank you for doing this. I'm here to learn more about AI. I don't have a tech background though I dabble around the edges a bit. I don't really have a specific question. Just learning all I can.

Jonathan Addington's avatar

OpenAI has consistently shown that they have more capabilities than they’ve released, how much more are they holding back?

Are there other companies out there that have products like this ready to drop?

Why did the openai CEO release chatgpt only to go on a world tour calling it as dangerous as , with the same similar regulatory needs.

Why does Facebook keep open sourcing their models? Assuming it’s not out of the goodness of their heart.

With the genie out of the bottle, what sort of safeguards are even possible to put in place on AI today? Especially when there are models as capable as stable diffusion that can be run remotely modern PCs.

What do you personally see coming?

--

I’ve read your writing since the very beginning of your first stint at Ars, I appreciate your viewpoints and taking up this topic.

Jim Harper's avatar

Has anything been done to debunk the "intelligence" part of the AI moniker? This stuff seems quite clunky relative to expectations/the hype.

How does background law (i.e. tort) apply to people deploying "AI" in ways that cause harm?

James Love's avatar

Do you see a role for mandating the sharing of training data as an essential facility with or without remuneration?

Nathaniel Reichman's avatar

What is the best way to determine who the niche players are in the AI-space? For example, some established audio-processing companies are clearly experimenting with AI, but I expect this technology to be disruptive to the professional audio/video community. Who else is doing work in this area besides the obvious big players?

Aaron Strauss's avatar

Here's what I don't understand about the current AI discourse: training-set/feedback/reinforcement learning has proved dominant over rule-based AI. Yet, when it comes to assuming AIs will be "super-intelligent" *in the real world* (not chess, Go, protein-folding), I haven't heard any of the dystopians explain what feedback mechanism even has the possibility of creating a threatening AI. Instead, to my lay ears, it sounds like "we'll, computers are logical and fast, ergo they must be capable of super-intelligence"--but that completely skirts the issue and seems to rely more on rule-based thinking. Have you heard folks discuss feedback mechanisms for super-intelligence? And might those discussions help clarify how to built AIs safely?

Daniel's avatar

How should schools address AI applications, like ChatGPT? What guidance would you give secondary school teachers in terms of what adjustments to policies and procedures they should employ?

Mama Lee's avatar

Is anyone working on robotic assistance for the elderly in their homes?

DWW's avatar

I like Daniel’s question above, what is an appropriate stance for an academic institution on, for example, chat gpt? Is it a tool like maths or does it dumb down / obviate the need for learning / enquiry? What’s the balance?

Chris's avatar

I know you're not an economist, but what is your reaction to this tweet (which as an economist I think is correct, and you seem to be on the side of the economists):

https://twitter.com/adamdangelo/status/1659965893210931201

"Economists seem to consistently be the most dismissive of AI existential risk concerns, out of all groups of people who think seriously about the future. Why is this and what can we learn from it?"

What is it we are missing, or conversely what is it we understand that others don't?

John's avatar

Can AI be used to effectively determine stock market trends and commodity prices?

Tj's avatar

oodles of words have been written recently demanding an AI pause or slowdown. Neglecting for a moment how poorly defined AI is, neglecting how poorly defined the AI threat is: is there any path to regulation? What rules could be put into place that would have any effect?